Our intuition tells us there’s a difference between innate advantages
and acquired ones. A swimmer born with webbed hands might have an
edge, but a swimmer who had skin grafts to turn feet into flippers would
pose a problem. Elite sport is unkind to the human body; high school
linemen bulk up to an extent that may help the team but wreck their knees. What about the tall girl who wants her doctor to prescribe human growth hormone because her coach said three more inches of height would guarantee her that volleyball scholarship: unfair, or just unwise? Where exactly is the boundary between dedication and deformity?
6 Imagine if Pistorius’ blades made
him exactly as biomechanically
efficient as a normal runner. What
I 1
- 1 -
Eindexamen Engels vwo 2010 - II
havovwo.nl
▬ www.havovwo.nl www.examen-cd.nl ▬
should be the baseline: Normal for the
average man? Or for the average
Olympian? Cyclist Lance Armstrong
was born with a heart and lungs that
can make a mountain feel flat; he also
trained harder than anyone on the
planet. Where’s the unfair advantage?
George Eyser’s wooden leg didn’t stop
him from winning six Olympic
gymnastics medals, including in the
parallel bars. But that was 1904; legs
have improved since then.