• Look for opposing viewpoints or counter-argument
• Does the author address opposing viewpoints clearly and fairly?
• Does the author refute the opposing viewpoint with logic and relevant evidence
• Identify the claim.
• Outline the reasons to support the claim.
• What types of evidence are used?
• Evaluate the evidence: Is their enough evidence provided and does it make sense?
• What emotional appeals are used?
• Is there language with strong positive or negative connotations?
• Does the author recognize or refute counter arguments?
Be aware of fallacies!!! See next slide....