Herbert's Death: The next day, Herbert goes to work at the factory and is killed in a terrible accident. The family is devastated by his loss.
The Compensation: Shortly after Herbert's death, the family receives £200 as compensation from the factory, fulfilling the first wish in a tragic manner.
Mrs. White's Desperation: Grieving and desperate, Mrs. White convinces Mr. White to use the second wish to bring Herbert back to life.
The Terrifying Knock: Late at night, they hear a persistent knocking at the door. Mrs. White believes it is Herbert, returned from the dead, but Mr. White is fearful of what they might see.
The Final Wish: As Mrs. White rushes to open the door, Mr. White makes the third and final wish. The knocking stops, and when Mrs. White opens the door, no one is there, implying that Mr. White wished Herbert back to his grave.