Crafting Effective Discussion Statements in English

• Engels
• Middelbare school
• vwo
• Leerjaar 5,6

Crafting Effective Discussion Statements in English

Learning Objective

Understand how to develop effective discussion statements based on a given news article.

Introduction to Discussion Statements

What are Discussion Statements?

• Discussion statements are assertive expressions that present a clear and debatable stance on a particular topic.
  
• They serve as the foundation for engaging in meaningful discussions and debates.
  

Characteristics of Discussion Statements:

• Clarity: Clearly articulating a viewpoint.
  
• Debatable: Allowing for varying perspectives and opinions.
  
• Specificity: Focusing on a particular aspect of the topic.

Reading the News Article

Read the provided news article.

Identifying Key Points

Identify the key points:

1. What is the topic of the article?
2. What is the main point made in the article?
3. What are the main opinions given, if any?
4. What are your personal takeaways and insights?

Creating Discussion Statements

Clearly State Your Position: 

Be concise and articulate in presenting your viewpoint to avoid ambiguity.

A discussion statement is not a question:

Make sure it is one declarative sentence. Don't mention your arguments to the statement.

A discussion statement is debatable:

You have to be able to be in favour or against the statement.

Use Appropriate Language:

Employ a range of vocabulary and expressions suitable for a B2/C1 level.

Provide Relevant Examples:

Support your statement with examples to enhance clarity and persuasiveness.

Examples of Good and Bad Statements

Well-Crafted Discussion Statements:

Example 1:

Due to rising health risks from air pollution, the UAE should shift to sustainable energy sources, prioritizing the well-being of citizens and the mostly migrant workforce.

Example 2:

The connection between health problems in outdoor workers and increasing air pollution in the UAE prompts a discussion on protective measures and reforms to reduce occupational health risks

Examples of Good and Bad Statements

Poorly-Crafted Discussion Statements:

1. Lack of Specificity:

•    "Air pollution in the UAE is not good."
  
•    Issue: This statement is overly vague and lacks specific reference to the issues highlighted in the article, such as health risks, migrant workers, and the impact of fossil fuel production.
  

2. Non-Declarative Statement:

•   "Is air pollution a problem because of fossil fuels in the UAE?"
  
•    Issue: This is a question rather than a declarative statement. Effective discussion statements should assert a position for debate.
  

Examples of Good and Bad Statements

Poorly-Crafted Discussion Statements:

3. Absolute Assertion:

• "Fossil fuels are the only reason for air pollution in the UAE."
• Issue: This statement oversimplifies the issue presented in the article, neglecting the complexity of factors contributing to air pollution, such as sandstorms and government policies.
  

4. Lack of Debate Potential:

• "Air pollution in the UAE is caused by many things."
  
• Issue: While somewhat true, this statement lacks specificity and doesn't invite debate or exploration of the specific factors discussed in the article.

Now create a discussion statement for the article you have read, and send it in. One statement per duo.

Engaging in Discussions

Have a group discussion about the selected statement.

Focus on:

• Reacting on what your classmates say
• Active listening
• Not playing "tennis"

Conclusion and Reflection